Most people will head straight to the review section in their search for the best air fryer toaster oven. We do not recommend that approach.

You should first identify the features you want in your air fryer toaster oven. Only then should you embark on the search for a unit that offers them. Here’s how you can do it.

Now we’re going to show you a separate narration of each of the best air fryer toaster oven america’s test kitchen one by one. Let’s start!

Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven America’s Test Kitchen 2023

1. Cuisinart Convection Toaster Oven Airfryer

The Cuisinart Convection Toaster Oven Air Fryer comes with a traditional style control dial. It can fry super crispy chicken wings in 20 minutes without oil and the need for preheat time. This oven can also preheat frozen pizza in a jiffy and grill steak in no time. In addition, this model can toast bread and bake a cake fast and evenly. It can oven fry up to 3 pounds of food at a time.

This model comes with a basket on top of the skillet for air frying without the drippings getting into the other components of the unit. It comes with an 1800-watt motor, heater, and fan to deliver high-heat airflow to ensure perfectly fried food with less noise.

With the Cuisinart convection toaster oven air fryer you can boil, bake, toast, reheat, and slow cook. It also includes features for proofing and dehydrating. In conclusion, all these functions make this unit one of the best air fryer toaster oven.

This unit features a stainless style body with interior light and a large viewing window. Its interior is non-stick and all accessories are dishwasher safe.

Pros

• Heats up fast
• Precise timer
• User-friendly dials
• Comes with extra accessories
• Affordable

Cons

• Exterior easily gets hot
• Air fryer basket rusts easily
• No replacement knobs available

2. Emeril Lagasse Power Air Fryer

The Emeril Lagasse Power Air Fryer 360 Combo is one of the best air fryer toaster oven combo in the market. It features 12 pre-set cooking functions including toasting, roasting, dehydrating, baking, slow cooking, and more.

Food is evenly cooked in this unit. Its 360-degree Quick Cook Technology where a whirlwind of heat surrounds the food from all sides for even cooking.

It features 2 analog dials to set the time and temperature. A third dial allows you to choose the cooking function. Temperature, cooking time, and cooking modes are displayed in a backlit LCD digital display. It also comes with a stainless steel that is easy to clean.

Pros

• 12 pre-set functions
• Stainless steel construction
• 5 powerful heating elements

Cons

• Cannot be used in Formica or laminate countertops and under hanging cabinets
• Consumes too much electricity

3. Instant Omni Plus Air Fryer Toaster Oven

The Instant Omni Plus is one of the most user-friendly toaster ovens on the market. Mainly because the placement of its buttons makes operating this model a cinch. Both their location – beneath the display – and the description – easy-to-read icons – is the reason why.

Then comes its LED display. It saves you from guessing how much time is left before you can take out the meal by displaying the remaining cooking time. It also shows time/temperature settings as well as which of the nine preset cooking options you have activated.

Equally noteworthy are its dials. There are two of them, one on either side of this Air Fryer With Rotisserie, with the sharp LED display between them. You can use the dials to activate cooking functions, set cooking time and the cooking temperature.

We were equally impressed with the accessories on offer. Apart from the rotisserie spits and forks, its package includes a rotisserie lift, an oven rack, one cooking pan and an air fryer basket. All of these are the reason why you can air fry, dehydrate, broil, bake and slow cook.

Pros

• Comes with six accessories
• Lets you activate 11 programs with the touch of a button
• Can roast a whole chicken at once

Cons

• Has only 1-year warranty

4. COSORI CO130-AO Air Fryer Toaster Combo

Compared to traditional frying, the COSORI CO130-AO uses 85% less oil. Some foods do not require any oil when using the air fryer. It is easy to use and comes with multiple functions and features making it the best air fryer oven combo.

This 30-liter air fryer toaster combo comes with 12 functions including toasting, baking, broiling, fermenting, dehydrating, and reheating pizza. In addition, it can also bake cookies and comes with a rotisserie. This model features intuitive controls with temperatures ranging from 180 to 4500F, as well as a Keep Warm feature.

This COSORI air fryer comes with a conventional dial, interior light, and LED screen. Its Keep Warm mode maintains a temperature of 1600F or above allowing food to remain hot for up to 12 hours.

This large capacity air fryer toaster oven can fit a 12-inch pizza, 6 slices of bread, and a whole chicken.

Pros

• Fast cooking time
• Multi-function
• Powerful motor
• Digital Display
• 100% safety protection

Cons

• Requires preheating
• Bulky

5. GoWISE USA GW44800-O Deluxe Air Fryer Oven with Rotisserie

Multiple features of the GoWISE USA GW44800 make it a must-have. Most important among which is its family-sized cabin. This model offers 12.7-quarts of cooking space which, together with its 3 rack levels, allow you to prepare hearty meals for the entire household in one batch.

The built-in rotisserie is equally useful. You can use it to prepare tenderloins, whole roasts, whole chicken, roasted vegetables and blackened fish. Its consistent rotation and placement in the middle of the air fryer will ensure that your meal is as tender on the inside as it’s crispy on the outside.

Also on offer are 10 accessories and a 50-recipe book. The former includes two rotisserie steak cages, two mesh trays, one shallow mesh basket, and an oven rack, among other items. The latter, meanwhile, contains formulae of dishes specifically made for this air fryer.

Further sweetening the deal is this model’s control panel. One large LED display is surrounded by three rows of icons, all of whom are easy to identify. The first row is populated by major settings i.e. time, temperature, light, rotisserie and the other two are mostly cooking options that this unit offers.

Pros

• 12.7-quarts of cooking space
• Comes with 10 accessories
• Has an easy to use control panel
• Backed by one-year warranty

Cons

• Warranty only covers US-based users

6. Philips Kitchen Appliances Digital Twin TurboStar Airfryer XXL

Philips produced some of the first air fryers to hit the market, and they maintain a robust presence in this vertical today. Although their air fryers are not cheap, you get class-leading performance married to great build quality and the heritage of the Philips brand.

The key selling point with this digital air fryer is the fat reduction technology that works to eliminate the excess fat from your food. When you combine this with the fact you won’t need to use much cooking oil either, you can create delicious fried dishes that are also easy on the waistline.

If you’re cooking for a family of 4, the capacity of this model gives you more than enough space.

Instantly hot and ready to roll in seconds, just load in your favorite foods and you’re ready to tweak the time and temperature.

As with all air fryers, you can expect your food crispy and golden outside, but tender and juicy inside.

You can do much more than air fry with the Philips, though. Other cooking functions include: Toast, Dehydrate, Reheat, Bake, Roast, Grill.

You can also take advantage of 5 handy presets to get fast food without the guilt.

Aside from the fact this is one of the most expensive air fryers out there, we can’t find much else to knock about this excellent example.

Pros

• 5 presets punched in
• Fat reduction technology
• Impeccable brand heritage

Cons

• Pretty pricey

7. Instant Pot Vortex Pro 9-in-1 Air Fryer, 10 Quart.

The INSTANT POT VORTEX is perfect for an entire family of 6-10 people. Or, alternatively, if you prefer to entertain more and frequently, this appliance will give you more time to spend with the guests rather than in the kitchen. Very highly rated and expert-recommended, this is the best air fryer toaster oven consumer reports 2023.

With the best rotisserie function, a spit, and the capacity to load an entire chicken – this is the best rotisserie 10-quart air fryer without a shadow of a doubt.

It is very safe with no blast of hot air to heat up the kitchen in the scorching heat of Texas. While saying that, it is also energy efficient and comes with accessories so you won’t fret when taking your air fryer on the picnic.

Pros

• Huge cooking volume available
• Easily detachable parts for cleaning
• Smooth functioning and satisfying
• Safe to use and cooks evenly

Cons

• Needs a credible amount of space to vent out hot air

What is an Air Fryer Toaster Oven?

You probably already have a toaster oven. Are you considering purchasing an air fryer? The egg-shaped ovens are increasing in popularity and cooks love how they can make everything from banana bread to chicken tenders.

Enter now the air fryer and toaster oven combo!

A toaster oven can handle a wide range of tasks from toasting bread to reheating, baking, and broiling. An air fryer does not actually fry. It is a miniature convection oven that circulates hot heat around food to make crunchy bites. An air fryer deep fries without the Trans fats that comes with cooking oil.

An air fryer toaster oven is a convection oven with fans operating at high speed to make your food crisp and brown. In some models, you can slow cook, roast on a rotisserie, or dehydrate food.

Every homemaker has heard of oven toasters and air fryers. Both kitchen appliances have been lifesavers for the busy cook! But, wait, have you heard of an air fryer toaster oven? The best air fryer toaster combines the best qualities of these two multipurpose workhorses!